Leading with Authenticity: Why Most Leadership Training Gets It Wrong

Authentic leadership isn't about wearing your heart on your sleeve or sharing your weekend plans in team meetings.

I've been coaching executives for over 18 years now, and the number of leaders who confuse authenticity with oversharing would make your head spin. Just last month, I had a CEO tell me he was "being authentic" by telling his entire leadership team about his marriage troubles during a budget review. That's not authentic leadership. That's just poor judgement dressed up in buzzword clothing.

Related Reading:

• Location Shop Leadership Advice
• Place Group Business Posts

What Authentic Leadership Actually Means

Here's what the leadership gurus won't tell you: authenticity in leadership isn't about being the same person at work that you are at home. Thank God for that, because my home persona involves far too much swearing at the cricket and questionable fashion choices.

Authentic leadership is about consistency between your values and your actions. It's about making decisions that align with who you are at your core, even when it's inconvenient or unpopular.

I learned this the hard way back in 2019 when I had to let go of my top performer because they were undermining team culture. Everyone thought I'd lost my mind. The quarterly numbers took a hit. But six months later, the team was stronger, more collaborative, and productivity had actually increased. Sometimes being authentic means making the tough calls that others won't.

The Three Pillars of Authentic Leadership

1. Self-Awareness (Not Self-Obsession)

The difference between self-awareness and narcissism is about as wide as the gap between Melbourne and Perth, yet most leadership development programs treat them as the same thing.

True self-awareness means understanding your triggers, your biases, and your impact on others. It doesn't mean you need to announce every emotion or thought that crosses your mind. I've seen leaders who think "radical transparency" means they should share every doubt, fear, or random observation with their team.

One of my clients, a brilliant operations director in Brisbane, used to start every meeting by explaining how she was feeling that day. Anxious about the budget. Frustrated with head office. Worried about her daughter's exam results. She thought she was being authentic. What she was actually doing was creating anxiety in her team and making herself the emotional centre of every interaction.

Emotional intelligence training can help leaders understand the difference between self-awareness and emotional dumping. It's about knowing yourself well enough to regulate your impact on others.

2. Values-Based Decision Making

This is where most leaders fall down. They can recite their company values like a Sunday school lesson, but when crunch time comes, those values vanish faster than free beer at a tradies' lunch.

Authentic leaders make decisions based on their core principles, even when it costs them. I remember working with a manufacturing company in Adelaide where the CEO discovered their biggest client was cutting corners on safety standards. The contract was worth $2.3 million annually. The CEO could have looked the other way, made some gentle suggestions, or found a dozen ways to rationalise continuing the relationship.

Instead, he terminated the contract. His authentic leadership style meant he couldn't compromise on worker safety, regardless of the financial implications. The company struggled for eight months, but they attracted three new clients who valued their integrity. Sometimes authenticity is expensive upfront but pays dividends in reputation and team loyalty.

3. Consistent Communication

Here's what drives me mental about modern leadership advice: everyone's obsessed with charismatic communication styles. You don't need to sound like a TED talk presenter to be an authentic leader.

Some of the most authentic leaders I know are quiet, thoughtful people who choose their words carefully. Others are more direct and energetic. The key isn't your communication style—it's consistency.

Your team needs to know what to expect from you. If you're naturally direct, be direct. If you're more collaborative in your approach, lean into that. But don't try to be someone you're not because you think it makes you look more "leadership-y."

The Authenticity Trap

There's a dangerous misconception that authentic leadership means you can't grow or change. I've heard executives say things like, "This is just who I am" to justify everything from poor time management to explosive tempers.

Authentic leadership isn't about being static. It's about being genuine in your growth process. When you recognise a weakness or blind spot, address it honestly. Don't pretend you've always been perfect, but don't use "authenticity" as an excuse to avoid improvement.

Time management training for leaders often reveals how leaders struggle with prioritisation because they haven't authentically assessed their own productivity patterns. Being authentic means acknowledging where you need support.

Building Trust Through Vulnerability (The Right Kind)

There's a massive difference between strategic vulnerability and emotional incontinence. Authentic leaders share appropriate struggles and uncertainties with their teams, but they do so with purpose.

Strategic vulnerability might look like:

• Admitting when you don't know something
• Acknowledging a mistake and outlining how you'll prevent it recurring
• Sharing a relevant personal challenge that helps your team understand your perspective
• Being honest about difficult business realities while maintaining confidence in solutions

Emotional incontinence looks like using your team as a therapy session, creating drama where none existed, or making your personal problems everyone else's burden.

I once worked with a fantastic leader in Sydney who was going through a divorce. Rather than pretending everything was fine or oversharing details, she simply told her team, "I'm dealing with some personal challenges that might mean I'm occasionally less available for non-urgent matters. Please flag anything time-sensitive, and I'll make sure you have what you need." That's authentic vulnerability. Professional, honest, and focused on minimising impact on others.

The Australian Context

Australian workplace culture has some unique advantages when it comes to authentic leadership. We're generally less tolerant of corporate BS and fake enthusiasm than other cultures. This creates an environment where genuine, straightforward leadership can really thrive.

But it also means Australian leaders can sometimes confuse being "real" with being unprofessional. I've seen Melbourne executives think that swearing in meetings makes them more authentic, or Perth managers believe that rejecting any form of corporate structure shows their genuine personality.

Authentic leadership in the Australian context means being professionally genuine. You can be direct without being rude. You can be approachable without being unprofessional. You can challenge corporate nonsense without creating chaos.

Practical Steps for Developing Authentic Leadership

Start with values clarification. Most leaders can't articulate their core values beyond generic corporate speak. Spend time identifying what you actually stand for, not what you think you should stand for.

Then test those values against your recent decisions. Are you living them, or just talking about them? This exercise can be uncomfortable, but it's essential for authentic leadership development.

Work on conflict resolution skills because authentic leaders often find themselves in difficult conversations. When you lead with integrity, you'll occasionally need to have uncomfortable discussions about performance, behaviour, or strategic direction.

Develop emotional regulation without losing emotional intelligence. You want to be responsive, not reactive. This means managing your emotions without suppressing them or pretending they don't exist.

The Long Game

Authentic leadership isn't a quick fix or a performance technique. It's a long-term approach that builds sustainable influence and trust. In my experience, leaders who embrace authenticity—properly understood—create stronger teams, better business outcomes, and more fulfilling careers.

But it requires courage. It's easier to hide behind corporate personas and management speak than to show up as your genuine professional self every day. Authentic leadership means taking responsibility not just for what you say, but for who you are as a leader.

The payoff is worth it. Teams led by authentic leaders show higher engagement, better performance, and greater resilience during challenging periods. More importantly, these leaders sleep better at night knowing they're building something sustainable rather than just managing impressions.

In a business landscape full of leadership fads and management trends, authenticity remains the most reliable foundation for long-term leadership success. But only if you understand what it actually means.